I'll start...

1) Clumsy
2) Dreamy
3) Papa
4) Handy
5) Brainy (I've warmed up to him lately)

__________________
Have a Smurfy Day!

If anyone can tell me how to get the Smurf in my avatar pic, please let me know! Handed out at movie premiers apparently.

Lazy is my favorite.

Then Smurfette, Baker, Grouchy and Brainy

__________________
Lacey

Papa
Smurfette
Clumsy
Grouchy
Brainy

Papa
Smurfette
Clumsy
Handy
Jokey

__________________
Mr Bill

Astro Smurf, is my favorite
The Smurflings, Sassette is my favorite
Wild Smurf
Clumsy
Clockwork

Wandy

I listed Papa at the top of my list. He has always been at the top, however after seeing the movie, Clumsy has moved to the top.

__________________
Mr Bill

Vanity Smurf is always funny.

I like Grouchy too (my avatar)

Hefty I always liked because he's the only one that has a tattoo.

Harmony Smurf since we're both musicians

I don't know about the 5th one... Perhaps Shy or Timid Smurf (is there one?)

__________________

Wait just a minute are you calling Harmony a Musician? lol

__________________
Mr Bill

haha, hey now, he tries!

__________________

That I will give him. I just hope you are not putting youself in a class with him. lol
Honestly it was very hard to pic a favorite, or top 5. Until you asked the question, I had never thought about it. I know I said Papa was my favorite, but that is only because my daughter and two step children always called me Papa. Not Papa Smurf though. I just related to him because I love everyone.

__________________
Mr Bill